“I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately, to front only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived.”
The soft life movement promises freedom from hustle culture’s death grip. You’ve seen the TikToks. You’ve saved the Instagram posts about boundaries and slow mornings. You genuinely, desperately want to stop checking emails at midnight.
So why are you still doing it?
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: wanting change and actually changing are separated by a psychological chasm that most self-help content tiptoes around while holding a matcha latte.
In my previous article about reclaiming your life from hustle culture, we covered what needs to change.
Then dozens of readers slid into my inbox asking the same question:
“Why is this so hard to actually do?”
Because transitioning to a soft life isn’t a decision — it’s a psychological journey. A messy one. With plot twists.
Back in the 80s, psychologists James Prochaska and Carlo DiClemente studied how people kick destructive habits. What they found became the Transtheoretical Model: five stages of change that everyone cycles through when transforming their life — whether quitting smoking, rebuilding boundaries, or trying to stop doom-working at 1 a.m.
And here’s the kicker:
Most people fail because they don’t know which stage they’re in.
The same framework that helps people overcome addiction applies perfectly to breaking up with hustle culture and embracing the soft life.
Psychologists call this “precontemplation,” which is academic speak for:
“You’re in denial and slightly insufferable about it.”
You don’t think anything is wrong. This is just adulthood, right?
Sure, you’re exhausted. You haven’t had a real vacation since the Obama administration. Your partner is quietly Googling “emotional support pigeon.” But that’s normal…right?
No.
You just can’t see it yet because your entire identity is duct-taped to being The Hard Worker™ — the person who answers Slack during dinner and flexes about surviving on four hours of sleep like it’s a talent.
To you, the soft life looks weak. Lazy. For people who “aren’t hungry enough.”
But here’s what’s actually happening: Your brain is protecting itself from change by rationalizing everything.
Malcolm Gladwell, the patron saint of quirky insights, once claimed mastery demands 10,000 hours. Well, you’ve done your 10,000 hours of ignoring your body’s warning signs.
Congrats — you’re an expert in denial.
Most only snap out of it after something dramatic — a health scare, someone else’s meltdown, or that random 3 a.m. whisper:
“Is this working?”
And your soul responds:
“Buddy… no.”
Welcome to contemplation, where you’ll spend six months (or six years) thinking about change while changing absolutely nothing.
You love soft life TikToks. You save Instagram posts about boundaries. You even have deep, earnest conversations about slowing down. And yet, you’re still working sixty-hour weeks like it’s the Hunger Games.
Why?
Because you’re trapped between two equally miserable futures.
Option A: Keep hustling → burn out → destroy your health/relationships → and hit 50 wondering where your life went.
Option B: Embrace the soft life → risk stagnation, losing respect, or financial insecurity → maybe die alone clutching a scented candle.
This is where people become “chronic contemplators” — master collectors of self-help content who never actually do anything.
They make plans that always start after the next big project. They cycle between inspiration and cynicism, sometimes in the same afternoon.
Prochaska’s research found that another 40% of people sit in contemplation, recognizing the problem but paralyzed by ambivalence.
The psychological barriers here are brutal:
But here’s the truth:
Thinking feels productive, but it’s just procrastination in a cute outfit.
What gets you unstuck? Usually hitting emotional capacity or getting permission from someone you respect. Sometimes it’s reframing the whole thing as an experiment: try the soft life for three months and see what happens.
If you hate it, hustle will still be there. It always is. Like glitter. Or British weather.
The key insight from behavior change research is this: contemplation isn’t failure; it’s a necessary stage. But you can’t live there forever.
Congratulations, you’ve decided to change. Welcome to preparation — where “I should change” becomes “I’m doing this on Tuesday.”
Only 20% make it here.
This stage is practical and emotional. You:
You also do the essential identity work that most people skip:
Years of hustle culture leave a lot of people realizing they have no idea what they enjoy.
Your soft life needs to be yours, not an Instagram aesthetic. Maybe it’s four-day weeks. Maybe it’s actually taking your vacation days. Maybe a complete career pivot. The specifics matter less than whether they align with what you genuinely want.
Here’s where people get stuck:
You can move to Bali and still answer emails five times an hour. Geography won’t save you.
As the Stoic philosopher Epictetus taught, external circumstances matter less than our relationship to them.
Preparation ends when the cost of staying becomes greater than the fear of leaving.
Ah yes, action is where the real chaos begins.
You’re setting boundaries.
You’re saying no.
You’re living some version of the soft life.
And it is uncomfortable as hell.
Nobody warns you about dopamine withdrawal. Hustle culture has been your drug. Now you’re detoxing, and your brain hates it. You feel restless and anxious, like you’re forgetting something. You’re not.
That feeling is called “not being overstimulated.”
Then comes the identity crisis. You thought you’d feel free, but instead you feel lost. You’ve spent years defining yourself as “the hard worker” or “the ambitious one.” Take that away, and who are you? The afterimage is so strong you can barely see what’s actually there.
The soft life strips away your distractions. Suddenly you can see the parts of yourself you ignored. Some people love this. Others immediately try to run back to work just to avoid introspection.
Meanwhile, the peanut gallery chimes in:
Translation: You’re doing something they’re scared to try.
This is where Stoicism actually becomes useful. Ancient Stoic Marcus Aurelius —the guy literally ran an empire — still wrote about choosing inner peace over the world’s expectations.
You can’t control what people think about your soft life choices.
You can’t control whether you get passed over for promotions.
You control you.
That’s it.
Expect setbacks.
Expect doubt.
Expect to feel weird for a while.
It takes three to six months for soft-life habits to stop feeling like rebellion.
Six months to a year in, you hit maintenance. The soft life feels less like a performance and more like… normal.
Boundaries take less effort. Your identity is shifting. But it’s never automatic.
Here’s what nobody tells you: the soft life requires continual, conscious choice. You’re swimming upstream in a culture addicted to grind.
Prochaska found that maintenance requires different skills than action—you need strategies to prevent relapse and ways to integrate your new lifestyle into all areas of life.
The soft life evolves as you evolve. What was restful six months ago might feel boring now. What was “enough” might become too much—or too little.
That’s not failure — that’s growth.
And yes, you’ll relapse. Something stressful happens, and suddenly you’re doom-working at 1 a.m. again like it’s 2019. That’s not failure — it’s data.
Behavior change researchers emphasize that relapse is normal, even expected. What matters is how quickly you notice and course-correct.
What does the relapse tell you? Maybe a boundary needs reinforcing. Maybe you need more community support. Maybe you haven’t fully processed what you gave up to gain the soft life, and there’s grief work to do.
Long-term maintenance requires regular self-check-ins, community with others making similar choices, a sense of purpose beyond productivity, a reasonable financial cushion, and the flexibility to evolve your version of rest.
Eventually—usually after one to two years—your identity fully aligns with your new values. The pull of hustle culture feels foreign instead of tempting.
You stop performing productivity. You start living deliberately.
Here’s the paradox:
It takes discipline to live easily.
Boundaries are a daily practice.
Rest is a skill.
“Enough” is a lifelong commitment.
The soft life isn’t passive—it’s an active choice to protect your well-being in a culture that will happily extract everything from you.
The Stoics understood this centuries before hustle culture existed. They practiced voluntary discomfort to appreciate ease. They optimized for a well-lived life, not short-term wins.
Marcus Aurelius, despite being emperor of Rome, wrote extensively about the importance of inner tranquility over external achievement. That’s the real soft life: not permanent vacation or never working hard, but conscious alignment between your energy and your values. As he wrote in his Meditations:
“You have power over your mind—not outside events. Realize this, and you will find strength.”
He understood this long before hustle culture existed: success means nothing if you destroy yourself getting it.
The soft life combines psychological insight with philosophical wisdom—using stages of change to guide the practical journey while Stoic principles provide the mental framework to sustain it.
You can’t skip ahead.
You can’t bully yourself into the next level.
You can’t “should” yourself into the next stage.
Wherever you are is where you are.
The journey from hustle to soft life isn’t linear. You’ll loop back through these stages, especially during life transitions. That’s not failure—that’s being human.
The soft life isn’t a trend. It’s a return to sanity.
You don’t need a 10-year plan.
You don’t have to figure everything out today.
You just need to know which stage you’re in and what that stage asks of you.
Everything else is details.
The only way out is through. And after years of being told that easy is lazy and rest is weakness and enough is never enough, choosing the soft life might be the hardest, bravest thing you do.
Prochaska’s research offers one final insight worth remembering:
“The only real mistake you can make is to give up on your ability to change.”
So… where are you in the journey?
And what’s your next move?
DISCLOSURE: In my article, I’ve mentioned a few products and services, all in a valiant attempt to turbocharge your life. Some of them are affiliate links. This is basically my not-so-secret way of saying, “Hey, be a superhero and click on these links.” When you joyfully tap and spend, I’ll be showered with some shiny coins, and the best part? It won’t cost you an extra dime, not even a single chocolate chip. Your kind support through these affiliate escapades ensures I can keep publishing these useful (and did I mention free?) articles for you in the future.
READ NEXT
